Category: GmailCategory: Gmail
A recent Dense Discovery newsletter came my way with a subject line that made my heart sing: “Breaking up with Gmail,” which is a familiar topic around here!
“I went with Fastmail, a small Melbourne company (represent!) with a solid reputation. Its migration tool pulled everything across via IMAP in a few hours and mirrored my Gmail labels. On my laptop I use the web interface and don’t miss a single feature. On my iPhone, I can still use the native Calendar and Contacts apps, and Fastmail’s own app for email (it’s good). When I made a mistake during my custom domain setup, an actual human replied to my support request within a day with an answer that helped. I’d forgotten that was possible.”
Yes, there’s definitely some friction to leaving an email platform that maybe you’ve used for decades. But if using a tool just doesn’t sit right with you anymore, it’s worth the effort.
And as Kai explains, it’s not always going to be a clean cut, saying “too many clients and collaborators live in Docs and Sheets.” I’m in the same boat. But the act of moving our main email inbox to another company that values privacy and actually providing customer support feels good.
Tired of Gmail?
Try Fastmail.
Try Proton (50% off deal right now for Black Friday).So, “Google makes a privacy policy exception to use your Gmail and Photos data for ads,” according to Android Authority:
“This doesn’t mean Google automatically scans your private emails and photos to serve ads. The exception concerns information users choose to share with eligible services. Google also maintains that it doesn’t disclose personally identifying details, such as your name or email address, to advertisers without your permission.”
Everything is seemingly a grey-area when it comes to what Google is doing these days with AI and your beloved email. Oh, and Google cutting down 250,000 trees for a data center. Sure, why not?
As we’ve talked about on multiple member calls, you don’t need to leave Gmail and shut down your account tomorrow, it’s a process. Decoupling from Gmail also means figuring out how to decouple from Google Drive, Calendar, and so much more.
The biggest thing; start small. Sign up and try Fastmail or Proton (get 60% off a 12 month plan, affiliate link), and give is a test drive. Subscribe to a few newsletters and FWD some emails from your Gmail account into your new inbox.
Explore alternatives to Drive with Infomaniak’s kDrive or Proton Drive (affiliate link). There are many options out there!
Again, I’m not telling you which service is the best. You need to start an account with some of these services and see what feels right to you. If you’ve been using Gmail for 15+ years, a lot of these new services are going to feel alien, so remember to break up with Gmail at your own pace.
I hosted two “Let’s Break Up 💔 With Gmail” calls last week, and one guest mentioned this as we were wrapping up on Friday:
“This was very helpful if for no other reason than just to know I’m not the only nut in the room.”
It’s such a relief knowing other people are facing the same challenges. That we’re not alone.
Because, at the end of the day, it’s not just about email, but also the lock-in with Google Calendar, collaborative docs, and photo management. This makes a move look harder to manage, and so then we never start.
And we landed on two big points:
- The replacement will never feel “perfect” because Gmail feels so familiar – some of us were beta-users of Gmail back in early 2004!
- Do we want to replace one “all in one” soultion with another? What will some of these companies look like in ten years?
A good place to start? Stop researching and just sign up for a free trial with another email provider like Fastmail or Proton (affiliate links) or Hey. Get a feel for them, because if the vibes are off, you’ll never switch over.
Start small. Switch something like your Netflix account first, then maybe a store account. There’s no need for a big announcement, to tell everybody about your move. Just update your email here and there as you migrate, and leave the critical accounts (like banking, work stuff) for later on.
Two people were bewildered by my recent Break Up With Gmail video call.
“What’s wrong with email?”
“I thought you wanted people to get back to email?!”
I’ve got nothing against email, it’s Gmail I’ve got a problem with.
Google harvests too much data, has too much control over what you see (or don’t see), and if you ever get locked out your account, good luck talking to a human to get that sorted out!
Sign up for Fastmail here to save 10% off your first year (affiliate link).

This Focus Escape Pod is a 90-minute group conversation for people who are ready to get away from Gmail and Google, but want a calm, chill, honest place to talk through what comes next. No pitches or demos or upsells. Just shared experiences, calm conversation, and practical paths forward.
Wednesday, February 25 from 12:00 PM – 1:30 PM EST
Things we’ll explore during this 90 minute call:
- Understanding the basics of forwarding messages, exporting your emails, and more.
- Real stories from people who left Gmail and discovered their work, relationships, and inboxes were fine!
- How others chose a new provider based on values like privacy or simplicity

This is a club for creatives, small business folk, and just about anybody else looking to break up with social media and big tech.
🏳️🌈🏳️⚧️🇵🇸
→ See our upcoming Zoom schedule
I’m Seth Werkheiser! Get in touch: seth@socialmediaescape.club
Subscribe via RSS (What is a RSS?)
